Poll: Where should we go for my birthday dinner?

by julie on October 29, 2008

Hello there! If you are new here, you might want to subscribe to the RSS feed for updates on this topic.

So for the past few (excessively busy) weeks, Terry has been bugging me about where I want to go for my birthday. “Sweetie,” he says, “You have to pick a place.”

I want to go somewhere new (so I can review it, like the consummate blogger I am) but I just can’t quite pick. Right now I have it narrowed down to Slim’s, Nectar and Honey (where I went to dinner with my mom last year, but I didn’t have the blog then so it doesn’t count). I’m also open to some other suggestions. So, what do you think?

For “other”, it has to be a place I haven’t yet reviewed and non chain, please. Not a greasy spoon, either. Pretty simple. The poll will be closed on November 7, and I’ll report back as soon as possible with a review.

(For the record, I have reviews of JeanRo, Akira, The Madison and Amarin forthcoming, so those places aren’t eligible.)

ETA: A little bird told me I should consider Nicola’s, so don’t be surprised if I ignore the poll all together and go to Nicola’s. I know, I’m no fun. I wish I knew how to edit the poll…

http://food.yatpundit.com YatPundit

I can’t speak to any of them, being from New Orleans, but I would say it depends on your mood. Which is the most romantic? Which is the bestest food? Which is the best for getting hammered?
http://spotoft.com Teresa

Slim’s all the way – the other two places don’t look like real food : )

Have a great bday! It’s Saturday right?
http://www.me-unplugged.com stef

mmm…nicola’s is good, good eats. also, south beach grill is good, if you like jeff ruby’s stuff, although i’d guess it’s similar to the precinct (although i haven’t been to that one yet). daveed’s in mt. adams is also very tasty, ooh! then head next door to the blind lemon and have a hot chocolate with amaretto whilst sitting in front of the fire in the courtyard. tasty AND romantic.
http://www.clarkstreetblog.blogspot.com/ WestEnder

I do not have a dinner suggestion. You don’t need my help for that. But after dinner it might be nice to go back home and share a big piece of the Bonbonerie’s chocolate-raspberry torte with a nice glass of wine in front of the fireplace (or burning trash can, whatever you do in OTR).

Happy B-day in advance
http://queencitysurvey.blogspot.com Dan

If you’ve never been to Nicola’s then I vote there!
http://obrientastings.blogspot.com/ Gary

While Nectar is good, I wouldn’t suggest it as a “special” place. Having moved to Cincy in May, we’ve had a couple of experiences there, including a theme dinner. Good, but not great.

Our experiences are probably mostly pedestrian but I’d go with someplace like Aqua, Beluga, Oceanaire or perhaps Hugo’s.

Good luck!
admin

Teresa’s– what do you mean “real food”? And I’m not revealing the exact date of my birthday. A girl has to have some mystery!

Stef– I thought about Jeff Ruby’s something, but we do their food fairly often. Plus, south of the river and Ruby’s = cigar smoke. Yuck.

Westender– actually, that’s part of the plan– the cake at least. I think I’ll have to make do with a space heater or a fire escape grill instead of a fireplace, though.

Dan–

Gary– Good to know w/r/t Nectar. I like Hugo’s, but I’ve already reviewed it. I like Oceanaire too, but I’ve reviewed it a couple of times. Still bummed they’re not doing lunch… Welcome to the city!
http://getinmahbelly.blogspot.com liz

honey > slims > nectar, in my opinion

i have not been to nicola’s but have heard a lot of good things. i also keep hearing good things about 20 brix.
http://cincinnatilocavore.blogspot.com valereee

I vote Slim’s. Not just great food but a very different dining experience.
Amber

Definitely going to have to go with stef and say Nicola’s. I have always left there having had a delicious meal and great experience. The bread basket alone makes the trip worth it!
Emily

My boyfriend and I have made Oceanaire are “Special Occasion Go-To Place” mainly becuase we spend a small fortune everytime we go. I would definitely tell you to try it out soon, but maybe not for your birthday. Have you ever had a Korean Stone bowl from Sung or the Korean place over in Covingtong? That’s something really neat to do and very different. I also suggest trying Wild Ginger’s new Hibachi grill, but get a reservation becuase they fill up fast and we had to wait like 2 hours last week on a Thursday night!!! It was well worth the wait. If you end up going to Beluga they have 1/2 price sushi on Wednesday now starting at 5:00, it’s a steal.
admin

Hi, Emily–

I’ve been to Oceanaire a couple of times now, and like it, but want to try something different. I love Sung– it was one of my first reviews (almost a year ago, golly) and Riverside is great, too. Thanks for the tip on Wild Ginger; I like Beluga as well, but my birthday’s not on a Wednesday (and we did Sake Bomb for my birthday last year. ).
suz

I say go to Nicola’s. It’s always good and good for a special occasion. It would be my choice.
Allison

Pitrelli’s in Mason. Charming little Italian place with the best eggplant parmesan in the city. I wasn’t wild about their dessert selection though. Go somewhere else for cake

Happy Birthday!
http://liberalfoodie.blogspot.com/ LiberalFoodie

slim’s. i really want to go there so maybe if I read another fabulous review, I’ll actually make plans to go there with the husband